Person

Thanks, I'll go and have an attempt at my ideas.

Thank you for the suggestions as well, it helped quite a bit.

Well the concept of a trolley problem is definitly feasible and would make an interesting quest.

But ah you contradict yourself somewhat in your questline idea. You stated that you didn't want to use revenge as a motive, but that's exactly what A's motive is.
Also I think most good aligned characters would side with Person B, since siding with A would involve destroying a family, slaughtering random guards and only fueling a persons quest for revenge.
Revenge is in general considered a bad notion, so I think this isn't exactly a trolley problem scenario.

But leaving the whole trolley thing out of mind, your pitch would definitly make for an interesting quest! But I definitly advise from killing of any original NPCs, since that could cause conflicts with other mods. Using entirely new NPCs would be a more elegant solution in my opinion.

Hehe, true. But that's just saying if revenge was A's motive.

How about A's weapon or something was possessed with a spirit who's seeking revenge on B and Person A is completely possessed, intent on killing B...

Hm... that might cause complications if the reward was this possessed weapon... especially if B isn't dead.

I'll think on it some more...

I see now, well sorry if it seems like I didn't think it through. The idea just came from the top of my head. I was giving Jon a second chance when I suddenly thought;
"Wouldn't it be funny if Auron was around here somewhere?".

Well, it was amusing at the time. You should've been there.

But I do see the problems, and I would feel sorry for the poor modder who tries to replicate the dress-sphere part in FF-X2. (I doubt really see the point in it. I'd choose a big party with lots of little conversations going on over a trio with a big wardrobe. Hehe, duck soup.)

Not recieving the breakage of forth walls, eh? I thought people don't mind unless the person does a pairing with the victim and their OC. Poor Sora... he's been through lots for a young teen.

Lastly, it does seem a bit selfish of me asking someone to put in;
"Sephiroth vs. Bhaalspawn. The match of the... well... ever!"
Sephiroth: What the- aw, crap. Why must you destroy everything that is good? *kills Bhaalspawn*

Well, that's my question cleared up, thanks.